The One That Got Away

Overview

19 audios · 7h 18m
Coulda, shoulda, woulda... our March challenge theme was "the one that got away."

Audios

The Pact

AJ · 13.1K plays · Jun 13, 2025
Ten years ago, we made a promise.
Tags: [M4F][Exes][Reunited][Mutual Infidelity][Long-Lost Lovers][Tower Bridge][Slow Burn][Yearning][Reminiscing][Catching Up][First Love][Look, Don't Touch][Panty Sniffing][Guided Masturbation][While I Watch][Clit Play][Clit Spanking][Dirty Talk][Fantasizing]+6
Duration: 30m

The One That Got Away

Harry · 7,032 plays · Apr 5, 2021
I always thought that we had something special.
Tags: [M4F][Storytelling][Breakup][Exes][Recounting][Dirty Talk][Intimate][Kissing][Oral][Blowjob][Fingering][Penetration][L-Bombs][Fantasizing]
Duration: 24m

Cupid’s Countdown: Alice’s Tea Party

Alice · 3,264 plays · Feb 14, 2025
You’re the one that got away, but Cupid might have a hand in making our paths cross once again.
Tags: [F4F][Speed Dating][Exes to Lovers][Flirting][Reminiscing][Compliments][Praise][Second Chance][Intimate][Desperate][Consent][Alleyway][Risky][Quickie][Grinding][Good Girl][Fingering][Masturbation][Valentine's Day][Series][Multi-Cast]
Duration: 17m

Dinner At Tiffany's

Faye · 5,713 plays · Apr 8, 2025
I said I never wanted to see you again, yet here we are — sharing a room at Tiffany's bachelorette weekend.
Tags: [F4F][FDom][Bridesmaids][Former Friends][Toxic][Awkward Reconnection][Reminiscing][Apology][Lingerie][Praise][Hair Pulling][Face Sitting][S'mores][Oral][Friends To Lovers][Good Girl]
Duration: 23m

MSN

Shaniqua Okwok · 3,841 plays · Mar 7, 2025
Ten years ago, we spent every night on MSN. Now, a swipe on Tinder reveals the impossible: the girl I never forgot.
Tags: [FF][WLW][Collab With El Wynne][Tinder][Reconnecting][Mutual Crush][Confession][Probation Officer][Romance][Flirting][Gentle][Praise][Oral][Fingering][Multi-Cast]
Duration: 16m

It's Been Months

Faye · 6,605 plays · Sept 17, 2024
It's been months since I last saw you and a lot has changed, but my feelings for you are always the same.
Tags: [F4F][Post-Breakup][Friends to Lovers][Reconnecting][Consent][Kissing][Eager][Oral][Fingering][Sweet][Gentle][Praise][Good Girl]
Duration: 16m

Fireflies

This Guy Eli · 5,351 plays · Aug 27, 2024
It's been a couple of years, but I've finally come back to our hometown and we meet in our usual spot.
Tags: [M4A][SFW][Reconnecting][Cuddling][Outdoors][Comfort][Our Spot][Nostalgic][Relaxing][Fireflies][Reflection][Appreciation][Missed You][Binaural][No SFX]
Duration: 21m

Let Me Refresh Your Memory

FlexxSounds · 6,267 plays · Jun 11, 2024
I know you're not in town for very long, so I'm glad you made time to see me.
Tags: [M4F][Friends to Lovers][Reconnecting][Flirty][Wine][Truth or Dare][Praise][Kitchen Counter][Missed You][Oral][Spit][Penetration][Passionate][Moaning][Spanking][Going Down on You][Gentle To Rough][Deep Voice][Finish Inside]
Duration: 21m

You Up?

Rina · 6,507 plays · Apr 12, 2024
Wouldn’t it be crazy if we did what we used to do in college?
Tags: [F4F][FDom][College Reunion][Friends to Lovers][Reconnecting][Whispering][Sneaky][Kissing][Breast Play][Praise][Oral][Messy][Fingering][Hold the Moan][Sweet to Feral][Aftercare]
Duration: 16m

Long Time Coming (Part 2)

Chris Yamez · 9,459 plays · Apr 23, 2024
You text me out of the blue five years later, but why did you wait so long?
Tags: [M4F][Exes][Five Years Later][Reconnecting][Nervous][Bitter][Emotional][Confession][L-Bombs][Passionate][Desperate][Penetration][Finish Inside][Praise][Attentive][Missed You][Music][Yearning][Series]
Duration: 34m

Long Time Coming (Part 3)

Chris Yamez · 9,145 plays · Nov 12, 2024
Don't ever let me leave you again.
Tags: [M4F][Old Friends to Lovers][Exes][Six Years Later][Soulmates][Book Release Party][Yearning][Reconnecting][Music][Dancing][Romance][Emotional][My Love][I Missed You][Penetration][Moaning][Intimate][Be Mine Again][L-Bombs][Series]
Duration: 25m

The Skin of a White Tree - Follow Sawyer (Sacrifices)

Naudio · 55.5K plays · Oct 28, 2023
I wasn't a good boyfriend back then, and I'm sorry for how I treated you.
Tags: [M4F][Spooky][Exes Reconnecting][In the Forest][Apology][Teasing][Flirting][Memory Lane][Confession][Masturbation][Oral][Going Down on You][Clit Play][Fingering][Forceful][Sweetheart][Spanking][Praise][Rough][In Public][Outdoors][From Behind][Penetration]+4
Duration: 28m

The Core of a Human - Follow Dylan (Sacrifices)

Zach Cowman · 27.1K plays · Oct 28, 2023
I've changed a lot over the years. It seems we both have. (CW: Loss of a Sibling)
Tags: [M4F][MSub][Reconnecting][Nerdy][Abandoned School][Suspense][Kissing][Oral][Mommy][Service Sub][Adoration][Use Me][Please][Alternate Endings][Going Down on You][In Public][Hold The Moan][Fingering][Encouragement]
Duration: 44m

Just This Once, One More Time

FlexxSounds · 3,684 plays · Sept 17, 2024
Thanks for reaching out. It really means a lot right now.
Tags: [M4F][Exes][Reconnecting][Bittersweet][Miss You][Infidelity][Outdoors][One Last Time][Begging][Daddy][Fingering][Penetration][Scratching][Slow][Intimate][L-Bomb][In Public][Emotional][Riding][Finish Inside]
Duration: 23m

10 Year Reunion

James · 3,630 plays · Apr 7, 2021
I haven't seen you since graduation—10 years ago.
Tags: [M4F][Reconnecting][Catching Up][Praise][Dirty Talk][In Public][High School Bleachers][Fingering][Oral][Blowjob][Penetration][Moaning][Back Inside You]
Duration: 15m

Star-Crossed at Starbucks

ButterscotchPirate · 14K plays · Mar 18, 2022
It's been four years since I've seen you, but I never forgot how you like your coffee.
Tags: [M4F][Former Friends With Benefits][Memory Lane][Confession][Car Sex][In Public][Fingering][Penetration][Finish Inside][Good Girl][Light Degradation][Kinky Ending]
Duration: 26m

Class of 2016 Reunion

Smash · 7,964 plays · Mar 18, 2022
It's been years since college, but nothing's changed.
Tags: [M4F][College Reunion][In Public][Kissing][Old Flame][Moaning][Penetration][Boundaries][Praise][Dirty Talk]
Duration: 13m

The Clothes I Bought You: Part 1

Zach Cowman · 125K plays · Mar 18, 2022
I was excited to meet my brother’s girlfriend—didn’t realize it was going to be you.
Tags: [M4F][MDom][Home for the Holidays][Exes][Infidelity][Oral][Fingering][Choking][Degradation][Daddy]
Duration: 29m

Stiff Vodka Soda Hugs

Girl In Dungarees · 6,525 plays · Mar 4, 2022
I really can’t believe you’re here right now. What are you doing in the city? Did you...come back for me?
Tags: [F4F][Exes][NYE][Emotional][Kissing][Moaning][Oral][Praise][Fireworks][Romance]
Duration: 17m